I counted all commenting accounts, excluding deleted accounts and known bots. I chose 19 subreddits from English Wikipedia’s Category:Subreddits, the 100 largest subreddits in 2019, and all of Reddit. I used January through September for each year between 2019 and 2026.
By Dmytro Krutytskyi, KissMyPost Research·Published ·Data through September 2026·13 min read
In January through September 2026, 11 of the 19 Wikipedia-listed subreddits had fewer commenters than half their peak. Commenting accounts increased on both sides of the collection change in June 2023, but some might be bots. Of the 98 largest 2019 subreddits, 71 have fewer commenters in 2026 than 2019.
Check your own subreddit
See when your subreddit is most active, what gets posts removed and who writes there.
Many of the famous ones got quieter
Some of the claims that Reddit is dying are based on a single subreddit, but that’s the one that seemed central to the whole site, and now it looks empty. So is it all of Reddit or just that one community?
I chose the famous places, as decided by the editors of Wikipedia. Very few pages were removed from this list, some lists, one meme, a picture puzzle, and two timed events; see Method. The source for this list was the English Wikipedia category of articles about subreddits. That resulted in 19 articles that qualify, on one open subreddit or a linked site or award, which I explain later. For each of those articles, the number of commenting accounts per month was counted, from January 2019 through September 2026. The same process was done for all of Reddit.
This gives me a count of accounts commenting in these communities, relative to their own peak year. Is this due to a cause, a broad shrinkage across Reddit, or is it just these accounts?
Let’s look at subreddits, what’s the current year so far, relative to their best year?
11 of the 19 are under half their best yearCommenters a month in January-September 2026 as a share of the subreddit's best year (2019-2025). 19 subreddits I selected from English Wikipedia's Category:Subreddits
Source: KissMyPost analysis of public Reddit comments. Average of unique commenting accounts a month, January-September of each year. Deleted accounts and 294,195 known bots excluded.
KissMyPost.com
The data shows that in January–September 2026, commenters on 11 of them are commenting at less than half the rate of their best year. (If you exclude NoFap and Herman Cain Award then it’s 9 of 17).
The deepest falls, with memorable names: r/IAmA is down to about one in fifteen of its peak monthly commenters, 2019 through 2025; r/HermanCainAward is down to about one in seventeen, by the same yardstick. r/antiwork has held onto about one in seven of its 2022 commenters. The biggest of these 19, r/AskReddit, still has about 71% of its peak year.
Some didn’t shrink, and I’m not overselling them as exceptions. r/bald, r/malefashionadvice, are both doing well, showing their top commenter total for January through September 2026, higher than any year before. r/AskHistorians, r/changemyview, r/Feminism, r/anime all had their peak year come after 2023.
None of these yet deserve the “survivor” label. Their peaks all come after a change in how comments were collected, which I’ll explain later. They’d also be inflated by bots that slipped through the filter, which I’m not counting. All I can say about r/bald’s growth is that it’s happening, not why. Here’s the monthly commenter count: 16,443 in July 2025, then 34,019 in August 2025.
Same with r/malefashionadvice: 6,512 in June 2026, then 13,949 in July 2026. Such jumps can move a yearly average; I haven’t looked into the causes. So I’m treating the 2026 numbers for those two as unsettled.
r/Art is at 205% of its 2024 level, but that’s because commenters jumped from 3,375 in November 2025 to 12,303 in December 2025.
I didn’t include r/The_Donald, a famous subreddit, in the above count at all. It was banned in June 2020, so its drop to zero there says nothing about interest in it waning.
Commenters a month in 19 subreddits I selected from English Wikipedia's Category:Subreddits, January-September
KissMyPost.com
Commenters a month in 19 subreddits I selected from English Wikipedia's Category:Subreddits, January-September
Best year is chosen from 2019-2025. r/HermanCainAward has commenters from October 2020. Both years in the last column come after the collection change. The articles for NoFap and Herman Cain Award are mainly about a website and an award.
Try itMember growth and activity for any subreddit you pick: Subreddits
The spikes, and what came after
Yearly averages can smooth out memorable moments, like those months where it seemed like everyone was on a particular thread. I chose four subreddits for a closer look, each of which is associated with a famous story. For each, here’s a monthly series, scaled against that community’s peak month.
Four famous subreddits month by monthCommenters a month as a share of each subreddit's busiest month, January 2019 to September 2026. Four of the six subreddits in the month-by-month CSV; r/AmItheAsshole and r/HermanCainAward are in the file, not on the chart
Source: KissMyPost analysis of public Reddit comments. Unique commenting accounts a month; deleted accounts and known bots excluded.
KissMyPost.com
I’m not sure why these famous subreddits have declined, but I do wonder if there’s a reason that isn’t captured in this data. One possibility is that Wikipedia articles are more likely to be written after the news cycle has peaked, so some of these drops are happening later than you might expect. Other people have suggested other reasons, including moderation, bans, and a blackout protest. There could also be factors that aren’t visible in this data, such as moves to newer subreddits, changes to the Reddit app, or something else entirely.
Reddit's commenting accounts grew on both sides of the June 2023 change
I wondered if the problem was Reddit’s own shrinking, so I tried to see if there was a site-wide decrease, but there wasn’t. I did this by counting the number of accounts commenting sitewide each month, excluding accounts I knew were bots or had been deleted.
Commenting accounts on Reddit grew within each collection periodAccounts that commented on Reddit each month, millions, January 2019 to September 2026
Source: KissMyPost analysis of public Reddit comments. Some of these accounts may be bots that the known-bot list doesn't catch. Compare only within each side of the June 2023 line.
KissMyPost.com
The line I’ve drawn above is an important piece of context for everything else on this page.
There was a lag between when a comment was written and when it was collected. For example, in January 2019, the median comment written on the 15th was collected 1,067 hours later. After the change, the median wait time dropped to 0 hours.
As you can see, the percentage of comments with deleted authors (the “deleted-author share”) decreased from 9.9% in 2019 to 3.7% in 2026. This probably means that the early years of this dataset are lower than actual, because any authors whose comments were deleted before they were collected don’t appear at all. This isn’t something I can measure, just an educated guess.
I’m not comparing Reddit to anything but itself, taking each side of this change in isolation, and showing a line that rises on both sides of the change. The writer’s own count, which is about 1.9× the number of accounts that commented at least once per month.
January–May 2023 vs. January–May 2019
It’s possible that some of these accounts are bots that have slipped through the filter. Remember to read these figures as accounts, not people.
For Reddit overall, I’m showing two ratios rather than multiplying them together into one number for 2019–2026. For individual subreddits, I’m chaining the ratios together as an approximation.
All 11 of these subreddits have fallen below half their peak value. That would create an opposing bias: unmeasured bots slipping past the filter, lifting the recent years relative to the past, making the decline appear smaller than it really is. The other bias, which I can’t remove, is that the peak year was chosen from the same data, which would tend to inflate the peaks. I’m comparing the biggest subreddits to a fixed baseline of 2019, which should reduce that bias.
Another possible explanation is that the 100 were ranked by 2019, so there could be some regression to the mean going on here. If you rank them by October–December 2018 instead, 78 of the 100 still show fewer commenters in 2026 than in 2019.
If you look at just the post-change years, 13 of the 19 famous subreddits have fewer commenters in 2026 than 2024. Using the same two years, the author’s count has Reddit with around a quarter more commenting accounts. Some of those may be bots.
It isn't only the famous ones
Editors don’t choose subreddits randomly, so it’s possible that the famous names are an unrepresentative group. To see if that’s the case, I tracked 100 subreddits that had the most commenters in the first nine months of 2019, whether they were famous or not, through to this year.
This time, the collection shift requires one extra step. Each subreddit is compared with itself before and after the change, then the two changes are multiplied together. The resulting figures are:
Most of the largest subreddits of 2019 have fewer commenters now98 of the 100 largest subreddits of 2019, by commenters in 2026 compared with 2019, chained across the June 2023 collection change
Source: KissMyPost analysis of public Reddit comments. Number of subreddits in each band. 1× means the same number of commenters as in 2019; bars left of it had fewer.
KissMyPost.com
Of the 98 largest subreddits from 2019 that I was able to trace, 71 had fewer commenters in 2026 than in 2019; adjusted for the change in collection in June 2023.
Two of the 100 were untrackable (r/The_Donald was banned). r/Cringetopia had no commenters in July through September 2023, so the post-switch change is not computable.
If one chains the comparison to 2019, the famous ones do a bit better: 10 of the 18 famous ones had fewer commenters in July-September 2026 than in 2019, compared to 71 of the 98 ones. The median is 97% for the famous ones and 66% for the others. However, the intervals of the shares below 2019 overlap:
Since there is no interval on the medians, one cannot claim a difference.
Try itSubreddits similar to one you know, sorted by size or growth: Find Subs
r/wallstreetbets after January 2021
Here are the number of posts per month there, averaged across all months from January through September in every year:
r/wallstreetbets posts a month, January-September of each yearPosts a month in r/wallstreetbets, January-September of each year
Source: KissMyPost analysis of public Reddit posts. Includes posts that moderators removed later. Deleted accounts and known bots excluded. I didn't check whether posts were collected the same way after June 2023, or how that would move post counts.
KissMyPost.com
The decline is steeper there than for commenters, but the overall trend is similar.
In January through September 2021, there were around 106,000 posts to r/wallstreetbets per month, excluding accounts on a list of accounts known to be bots. In January through September 2026, there were about one in fifteen of that. Commenter count has declined less, at around one-third of 2021 levels, though those counts include posts that were later removed by moderators. (The method of collecting this data was unchecked after June 2023; it’s not clear what effect that had.)
So, is Reddit dying?
I looked for an overall drop in the platform, but couldn’t find one.
The famous name alone doesn’t tell you how many commenters are there today, and commenter counts don’t capture readers either. It’s possible to be a remembered hub of Reddit, but be only a fraction of what it used to be. Meanwhile, the commenting accounts around it can keep growing.
Commenters are not the same as readers and lurkers (people who read but don’t comment) aren’t counted at all, let alone those who just vote or subscribe. And I’ve never even looked at subscriber numbers.
The collection method was switched in June 2023. This means that authors of comments that were deleted before they were collected do not appear in these numbers, and the early years are undercounted.
Also, before June 2023 there was some lag between when a comment was written and when it was collected, and this lag may have varied over the years, so the chained ratio here is only an approximation.
There are undoubtedly some bots in the data that aren’t on the known-bot roster, and they’d be counted as commenters, but the size of that miss has never been measured. It’s possible that some of the growth of Reddit over the years is due to bots. In any case, bots would tend to inflate more recent years, making declines look smaller.
There are few of the 71 subreddits that have nearly emptied out, such as r/xboxone, which had no commenters from January through September of 2026; I can’t correct for that, since I don’t know the cause. (A banned or closed subreddit would be treated as a drop.) Three of the 100 largest subreddits were also at zero commenters in 2026.
Finally, the peak year for r/AmItheAsshole is the year that the way collection was changed; so that peak is a blend of the months before and after the change. The subreddits that peaked after the change, or that have exceeded their previous record year, are not conclusive yet. Those peaks all come after the change, and if there were undetected bots, they’d contribute to those numbers too.
For this analysis, “fame” means having an English Wikipedia article, and the choice of which subreddits to include is made by editors, not randomly sampled. So a more general answer would be better based on the largest subreddits of 2019. Two of the nineteen, NoFap and the Herman Cain Award, have articles about the website and award rather than the subreddit. Adult subreddits weren’t pulled out separately.
The peak year for each subreddit was determined from the same data, so there’s some baked-in bias towards inflating those numbers. The biggest subreddits were anchored to a particular base year, which helps soften that bias. The ranking uses October–December 2018 as the base, and by that measure, 78 of the top 100 subreddits had fewer commenters in 2026 than 2019.
June 2023 was undercounted due to a blackout protest that started on June 12, 2023. If you drop June from every year, the above findings hold. The effect of the blackout itself wasn’t measured separately. I didn’t examine what caused many famous subreddits to have months where commenters doubled or halved relative to the previous month.
The “chain” from June 2023 assumes that the subreddit level is held constant, i.e., comparing January–May to July–September in 2023. This assumption could be violated by either the blackout or the season. The reasons for any shrinkage are not measured, whether it’s moderation, bans, protest, migration to new subreddits, or changes to the app.
Method
How the counts were made
KissMyPost.com
How the counts were made
Step
Rule
Famous subreddits
Articles in English Wikipedia's Category:Subreddits (snapshot November 2, 2026) about one community: every "R/<name>" title plus "Herman Cain Award" and "NoFap". 19 open subreddits. Left out: overview articles about groups of subreddits, a meme and a photo puzzle without a community of their own, and two time-limited events (r/place and The Button). r/The_Donald, banned in 2020, is reported on its own.
Panel
The 100 subreddits with the most commenters a month in January-September 2019, ranked from raw comments so none is lost to a missing name.
Measure
Average unique accounts that commented in a month, January to September of each year 2019 to 2026, so the partial year 2026 is compared with the same months.
Excluded
Deleted accounts and 294,195 accounts on a known-bot list (last added October 22, 2026).
Ratio
2026 divided by each subreddit's best year, 2019 to 2025.
Counted the same way, including posts removed later.
Seen before the plan
Rough monthly commenter averages for r/IAmA, r/HermanCainAward, r/antiwork, r/AmItheAsshole, r/AskReddit and r/wallstreetbets posts, from an earlier audit, and a trial count of Reddit's commenters for September 2026. Before writing the plan I had seen these.
Main data
Queried November 2, 2026; the retrieval-lag query and follow-up checks re-run November 11, 2026.
Planned before looking, and found while analysing
Each guess and what happened
KissMyPost.com
Each guess and what happened
Guess or finding
Result
The typical famous subreddit is below half its best year
Held, median 39%
Reddit had at least as many commenters in 2026 as in 2019
Held when compared directly, but that comparison crosses the collection change, so growth is given only within each period
More than half of the 100 largest subreddits of 2019 have fewer commenters in 2026
Held: 82 of 100 directly (not adjusted for the collection change), 71 of 98 chained
Combined share of Reddit's commenters; r/antiwork against a Wikipedia claim
Planned, not part of this article
Found: collection changed
Median time from a comment written on the 15th to its collection: 1,067 hours in January 2019, 1,015 in May 2023, 0 from June 2023 on. Deleted-author share of comments: 9.9% in 2019, 3.7% in 2026.
Reddit's growth, within each period
January-May 2019 to 2023: 1.9 times. July-September 2023 to 2026: 1.5 times. The two ratios aren't multiplied into one number for 2019-2026.
Panel on a chained ratio
2 subreddits can't be chained. 71 of 98 chained are below 2019, median 66% of 2019, 95% bootstrap interval 51% to 78%.
New period only, 2024 to 2026
13 of 19 famous subreddits had fewer commenters, against 24% more commenting accounts on Reddit (some may be bots).
Panel, new period only, July-September 2023 to 2026
75 of the 100 largest subreddits had fewer commenters in July-September 2026 than in July-September 2023.
Under half of the best year, famous against the largest of 2019
11 of 19 famous subreddits and 64 of 100 of the largest subreddits of 2019 are under half of their best year.
Accounts with at least two comments a month
1.8 and 1.4 times. Describes active accounts; doesn't filter bots.
Panel ranked by October-December 2018
78 of 100 had fewer commenters in 2026 than in 2019 (72 of 99 chained)
Without June of every year
11 of 19 famous subreddits under half; 82 of 100 panel subreddits smaller
Full year 2025 against the best full year
12 of 19 under half
Best three months in a row as the peak
12 of 19 under half
Panel ranked by 2021
85 of 100 smaller than in 2021
Missing comments
About 14 minutes from July 26, 2023. Expected to be too little to move a monthly average; not tested.
Conflict of interest: KissMyPost makes Reddit research tools. Funding: none.
Corrections: contact me; each fix gets a dated note on this page.
Questions people ask
Is Reddit dying?
Not “by commenting” accounts. January–May 2023: 1.9× the number of accounts as the same months in 2019. July–September 2026: 1.5× the number of accounts as July–September 2023. The author collected these two periods with different methods, so they were kept separate. It’s also possible that some accounts are bots that aren’t on the known-bots list. Since the overall number of Reddit accounts was collected differently in these two periods, the ratios weren’t multiplied together to get a single 2019–2026 number. In How many subreddits are there? commenter numbers were counted, not overall readers or visitors; those total numbers are unknown.
What happened to r/IAmA?
The number who commented at least once per month on r/IAmA during January–September 2019 (the peak year between 2019 and 2025) was about 29,981. In 2026, it was about 2,007, or about 7% of that peak. This series starts in January 2019; the busiest month was October 2019. Only public comments were counted, and the method of collection changed in June 2023, so earlier years are likely undercounted, and weren’t measured directly.
What happened to r/antiwork?
The number who commented at least once per month on r/antiwork during January–September 2022 (the best year between 2019 and 2025) was about 220,475. In 2026, it was about 31,466, or about 14% of that peak. This series starts in January 2019; the busiest month was January 2022. Only public comments were counted, and the method of collection changed in June 2023, so earlier years are likely undercounted, and weren’t measured directly.
What happened to r/wallstreetbets?
The number who commented at least once per month on r/wallstreetbets during January–September 2021 (the best year between 2019 and 2025) was about 221,292. In 2026, it was about 73,603, or about 33% of that peak. The number of posts to r/wallstreetbets, including those removed by moderators later, was about 106,262 per month during January–September 2021, but only about 7,050 posts per month during the same months in 2026. I haven’t checked if the method of collection changed after June 2023, and if so, what effect that had on these numbers. The busiest month was January 2021.
The data
The counts behind this article are available as files here, under a CC BY 4.0 licence; they can be reused freely.
CSVFamous subreddits, 2019 to 2026Commenters a month (January-September) in each of the 19 subreddits I selected from English Wikipedia's Category:Subreddits and r/The_Donald, best year and ratios.
CSVThe 100 largest subreddits of 2019Commenters a month in 2019 and 2026, the direct ratio, and the two within-period ratios and their chain.
CSVReddit by yearCommenting accounts and posts a month, accounts with two or more comments, and the share of comments with a deleted author.
CSVMonth by monthCommenting accounts on Reddit and in six famous subreddits, and r/wallstreetbets posts, each month from January 2019 to September 2026.
KissMyPost is a Reddit analytics tool: it reads a subreddit's history (posts, comments, removals, rules) and tells you when to post, what format works and who writes there. This study uses the same data: public Reddit posts and comments back to 2005.
Dmytro Krutytskyi is the founder of KissMyPost, a Reddit analytics tool. He studies what online communities talk about, who writes in them and how audiences overlap, and writes up what the data shows here, with the method and the numbers. Questions about the data, or need a cut we didn't publish? Write to him directly.
Krutytskyi, D. (2026). What happened to Reddit's famous subreddits. KissMyPost Research. https://kissmypost.com/research/what-happened-to-reddits-famous-subreddits