Skip to content

Data study

How to lose weight fast, according to Reddit: what commenters recommend most

What 1,470 randomly sampled Reddit replies tell people who ask how to lose weight fast, from 2021 to September 2026: the main method each one recommends, and how often there's no advice at all.

By , KissMyPost ResearchPublished Data through September 20268 min read1,497 views

When someone on Reddit asks how to lose weight fast, the advice they get most is plain: eat less and count calories. That's the main tip in 35.7% of the replies that recommend any method, in a random sample of replies in selected diet, fitness and general-question subreddits, from January 2021 to September 2026.

Search any phrase since 2005

See when a word or phrase took off on Reddit, in which subreddits and who used it.

Eat less. Among the comments that recommend a concrete method, 35.7% say to eat less or count calories, which is roughly a third of them and about twice as often as the next answer, a named diet like keto.

The thread is probably familiar to the reader, maybe even written by them. It’s a poster with an upcoming event who wants to lose some weight before it and asks Reddit for how to do so fast. Piled up in replies are a mix of useful advice, jokes, warnings, and occasionally a sermon on patience.

I wanted to know what all that fast weight loss advice on Reddit adds up to when you count it instead of skimming it. So I found the threads since January 2021 whose title matches a search pattern for "lose weight fast" and similar wordings, in a set of diet, fitness and general-question subreddits, and pulled the direct replies underneath that are at least 60 characters long. There were 9,335 of them. I took a random sample of 1,470 and had each reply labelled with the one method it recommends most.

The first surprise: Many replies recommend nothing, about a quarter offering no advice whatsoever. These can take many forms: returning a question, sharing a story, or making a joke. Another group says there’s no fast way, urging you to slow down. That leaves about two in three replies that name a concrete doable action.

Here's how the main advice breaks down:

What Reddit commenters tell you to doMain advice in a random sample of 1,470 top-level comments under threads asking how to lose weight fast, from 2021 to September 2026, with 95% intervals
Main advice in top-level Reddit comments under fast weight-loss threads, share of a sample of 1,470, 2021 to September 2026No advice: 25.2%. Eat less / count calories: 23.8%. A named diet: 11.1%. Exercise: 10.7%. No fast way, go slowly: 8.0%. Fasting: 7.3%. Cut specific foods or drinks: 5.3%. Drugs, supplements or a doctor: 5.2%. Another method: 3.4%.0%10%20%30%No advice: 25.2% of comments (95% interval 22.1% to 28.2%)No advice25.2%Eat less / count calories: 23.8% of comments (95% interval 21.5% to 26.4%)Eat less / count calories23.8%A named diet: 11.1% of comments (95% interval 9.3% to 12.9%)A named diet11.1%Exercise: 10.7% of comments (95% interval 9.0% to 12.4%)Exercise10.7%No fast way, go slowly: 8.0% of comments (95% interval 6.4% to 9.7%)No fast way, go slowly8.0%Fasting: 7.3% of comments (95% interval 5.7% to 8.9%)Fasting7.2%Cut specific foods or drinks: 5.3% of comments (95% interval 4.2% to 6.5%)Cut specific foods or drinks5.3%Drugs, supplements or a doctor: 5.2% of comments (95% interval 4.0% to 6.5%)Drugs, supplements or a doctor5.2%Another method: 3.4% of comments (95% interval 2.6% to 4.4%)Another method3.4%

Source: KissMyPost analysis of public Reddit comments in 2021 to September 2026, known bots excluded; n = 1,470 comments, years weighted by their number of comments.

Eating less or counting calories is the main advice in 23.8% of all replies, which is about as many as the replies with no advice at all. So if you post the question yourself, "eat less" is the most common real tip you'll get, but the non-answers keep pace with it.

A named diet and exercise come next, and they're about the same as each other. Each one turns up about half as often as eating less. I'd have guessed that exercise would be higher, since "move more" is the other half of the classic advice, but in this labelling, exercise comes out lower than I expected. One possible reason, not measured, is that a reply that says both counts only as eating less.

Fasting, cutting out one food or drink, and drugs, supplements or a doctor's visit sit further down, each well under one reply in ten. Keep in mind, though, that removed comments aren't in the data, so any risky advice that was taken down isn't counted.

It also matters how the labels work. Each reply got one main method, so a reply that says "eat less and walk more" counted as eating less. Eating less is the broadest category, which gives it the best shot at coming out on top, so I'd trust its lead more than its exact size.

I tried counting it seven other ways, too. I used each judge alone, only the replies both judges agreed on, no weights, no r/AskReddit, and so on. Eating less came out on top every time.

It depends where you ask

The answer differs a lot between subreddits. The share of method replies that say "eat less" ranges from 4% in r/fasting to 52% in r/loseit. r/AskReddit, where the biggest part of the sample comes from, sits close to the overall figure. The samples per subreddit are small, though, so I'd read the table below as rough.

Labelled comments by subreddit, and the share of method comments that say to eat less or count calories
SubredditComments in the sampleEat less, among method comments
r/AskReddit54734%
r/loseit32652%
r/Advice12934%
r/NoStupidQuestions11742%
r/keto7418%
r/teenagers5940%
r/intermittentfasting4919%
r/fasting374%
r/Ozempic32too few to show
r/AskMen2524%
r/diet23too few to show
r/Fitness_India13too few to show

No interval is shown for single subreddits; a share is shown only where at least twenty comments in the sample name a method.

Try itHow often a phrase like "calorie deficit" or "Ozempic" comes up on Reddit, month by month since 2005: Historical search

How the advice changed since 2021

No change that I can detect. The yearly shares for eating less, a named diet and exercise move around, but their 95% intervals overlap, so the sample can't separate the years from 2021 to 2026.

The top three methods, year by yearShare of top-level comments under fast weight-loss threads whose main advice is eating less, a named diet or exercise, from 2021 to September 2026
Share of top-level Reddit comments under fast weight-loss threads whose main advice is eating less, a named diet or exercise, by year, 2021 to September 2026Eat less or count calories: 25.6% in 2021, 25.4% in 2026. Exercise: 13.0% in 2022, 6.7% in 2026. Every year's intervals overlap.10%20%30%2021202220232024202520262021: eat less / count calories 25.6% of comments (95% interval 20.5% to 31.0%)2022: eat less / count calories 23.1% of comments (95% interval 17.3% to 29.7%)2023: eat less / count calories 21.1% of comments (95% interval 15.3% to 26.1%)2024: eat less / count calories 23.9% of comments (95% interval 18.0% to 29.9%)2025: eat less / count calories 24.8% of comments (95% interval 18.7% to 30.8%)2026: eat less / count calories 25.4% of comments (95% interval 19.9% to 32.7%)2021: a named diet 12.2% of comments (95% interval 8.8% to 15.8%)2022: a named diet 13.4% of comments (95% interval 9.4% to 17.8%)2023: a named diet 10.8% of comments (95% interval 6.6% to 15.6%)2024: a named diet 8.2% of comments (95% interval 5.0% to 12.2%)2025: a named diet 12.0% of comments (95% interval 6.9% to 18.5%)2026: a named diet 11.6% of comments (95% interval 6.6% to 17.4%)2021: exercise 10.6% of comments (95% interval 6.7% to 14.6%)2022: exercise 13.0% of comments (95% interval 8.3% to 18.6%)2023: exercise 10.3% of comments (95% interval 6.8% to 14.1%)2024: exercise 12.9% of comments (95% interval 8.6% to 17.4%)2025: exercise 9.3% of comments (95% interval 5.4% to 13.4%)2026: exercise 6.7% of comments (95% interval 3.6% to 9.8%)Eat less /countcaloriesA named dietExercise

Source: KissMyPost analysis of public Reddit comments, known bots excluded; n = 224 to 258 comments per year.

Exercise is a bit lower in the latest year, but its interval still overlaps with the previous years. And remember, the latest year goes only through September, so there’s not really a trend call here. A wobble like this, with a sample size like this? Mostly noise.

What about drugs, supplements or a doctor? Ozempic wasn't counted separately. I expected this group to show up more in recent years, given how much people talk about drugs like it. Here's what the sample shows:

Drugs, supplements or a doctor, year by yearShare of top-level comments under fast weight-loss threads whose main advice is a drug, a supplement or seeing a doctor, from 2021 to September 2026, with 95% intervals
Share of top-level Reddit comments under fast weight-loss threads whose main advice is drugs, supplements or a doctor, by year, 2021 to September 20264.3% in 2021 (95% interval 2.2% to 6.4%) and 5.0% in 2025 (2.3% to 8.2%); the intervals overlap.0%5%10%15%2021: drugs, supplements or a doctor 4.3% of comments (95% interval 2.2% to 6.4%), 254 comments labelled20214.3%2022: drugs, supplements or a doctor 6.5% of comments (95% interval 3.2% to 10.5%), 247 comments labelled20226.5%2023: drugs, supplements or a doctor 5.2% of comments (95% interval 2.4% to 8.2%), 232 comments labelled20235.2%2024: drugs, supplements or a doctor 5.9% of comments (95% interval 3.2% to 8.7%), 255 comments labelled20245.9%2025: drugs, supplements or a doctor 5.0% of comments (95% interval 2.3% to 8.2%), 258 comments labelled20255.0%2026: drugs, supplements or a doctor 3.6% of comments (95% interval 1.4% to 5.9%), 224 comments labelled2026 (to September)3.6%

Source: KissMyPost analysis of public Reddit comments, known bots excluded; n = 224 to 258 comments per year.

There’s no change, at least none detectable here. Medication, supplements or physician is mentioned as the main advice in about one in twenty replies in 2021, and it’s about the same in 2025. The intervals overlap, and this is a small category, so only a big jump would be detectable at this size.

The mix of subreddits also shifts from year to year, so even a real change could reflect who was asking where rather than how the advice itself moved.

How often commenters say there is no fast way

About one reply in twelve. 8.0% of the replies in the sample say there's no safe or lasting fast way, or tell the asker to go slowly, without naming a method.

"There's no fast way", year by yearShare of top-level comments under fast weight-loss threads that say there is no fast way and give no method, from 2021 to September 2026, with 95% intervals
Share of top-level Reddit comments under fast weight-loss threads that say there is no fast way, by year, 2021 to September 20264.7% in 2021 (95% interval 2.4% to 7.3%) and 9.8% in 2026 (6.0% to 14.2%); the intervals overlap.0%5%10%15%2021: no fast way 4.7% of comments (95% interval 2.4% to 7.3%), 254 comments labelled20214.7%2022: no fast way 8.5% of comments (95% interval 4.8% to 12.4%), 247 comments labelled20228.5%2023: no fast way 8.6% of comments (95% interval 5.2% to 13.3%), 232 comments labelled20238.6%2024: no fast way 7.5% of comments (95% interval 3.6% to 11.6%), 255 comments labelled20247.5%2025: no fast way 8.5% of comments (95% interval 4.1% to 13.6%), 258 comments labelled20258.5%2026: no fast way 9.8% of comments (95% interval 6.0% to 14.2%), 224 comments labelled2026 (to September)9.8%

Source: KissMyPost analysis of public Reddit comments, known bots excluded; n = 224 to 258 comments per year.

It looks higher in the latest year than in 2021, but again the intervals overlap, so I can't tell you the "slow down" crowd has grown. What I can say is that it shows up in every year of the sample, as a steady minority of the replies.

I'll admit I expected more of these. A thread that asks for speed seems like an obvious place for a warning. But as the main point of a reply, "slow down" stays a minority.

Not every thread in the set really asks for a method, either. Some titles worry about losing weight too fast, and others just tell a story. A separate check of the thread titles found that 74.2% of the labelled replies, about three in four, sit under titles that ask how to lose weight fast. So I ran the numbers again for just those threads:

Shares in all threads and in threads whose title asks how to lose weight fast
MeasureAll threadsThreads that ask
Comments with no advice25.2%15.9%
Comments that name a method66.8%77.3%
Comments that say there is no fast way8.0%6.9%
Eat less, among comments that name a method35.7%35.3%

Year-weighted shares of the labelled comments, without intervals.

In the threads that ask, fewer replies skip the advice. But the share of method replies that say to eat less is almost exactly the same, 35.3% against 35.7%, so the main finding doesn't depend on which threads I counted.

So if you ask Reddit how to lose weight fast, eating less is the single most common method you'll see named, though it depends on the subreddit. You'll also get a fair number of replies with no advice. Just remember that this is what people say. It isn't proof that any of it works, or that it's safe for you.

Is there another question you'd want answered from these threads? Let me know and I'll look at it next.

What this data can't tell you

Limits, one per row
LimitWhy
Recommend is not the same as worksA recommendation is what a commenter wrote. It says nothing about whether the method works or is safe, and upvotes and replies weren't measured.
Labels from two AI judgesEach comment was labelled by two AI judges and a third arbiter. A separate check of 107 random final labels agreed with 86 (80.4%); the rest differed in both directions, and the shares aren't corrected for them. The reviewer more often saw no advice where the judges saw a method (seven times against three), so the share that names a method may be slightly high. Multiplying the main share by that agreement rate gives 28.7%, a crude number that isn't an estimate or a bound, since the errors ran in both directions.
One main method per commentEach comment got one label, the method it names first or stresses most, so a comment that lists several methods counts for only one of them.
Eating less is the broadest categoryComments that combine eating less with exercise were counted as eating less, which makes it the most likely winner.
Top-level comments onlyOnly direct replies to the thread were read, not replies to replies, so advice given deeper in a thread isn't counted.
Only threads that match the search patternOnly threads whose title matches the pattern were considered, so threads that ask the same question in other words aren't counted.
The pattern misses some threadsAmong thread titles with a speed word and a weight word, the pattern caught 2,962 and left out 10,277. A separate check of 200 of the left-out titles found 21.0% still asked how to lose weight fast, so the pattern catches about 57.8% of such threads at best.
Threads with titles that do not askSome threads describe or worry about fast weight loss instead of asking how to do it. A separate title check marked them, and the shares for threads that ask are shown next to the shares for all threads.
Removed commentsComments that were removed or deleted aren't in the data, so any extreme advice that was taken down isn't counted, and how much that is wasn't measured.
Only the listed subredditsOnly the listed subreddits are covered; the results don't describe Reddit as a whole.
The mix of subreddits changesThe mix of subreddits changes from year to year and 2026 covers only January to September, so differences between years may reflect who was asking where, not a change in advice.
A stratified random sampleShares come from a stratified random sample of comments, one stratum per year, weighted back to each year's number of comments.
First thread keptWhen one person posted the same title in several subreddits, only the first thread was kept.
BotsAccounts on a known-bot list are excluded; bots that aren't on the list remain.

Method

Steps, in order
StepWhat
ThreadsPosts from January 2021 to September 2026 (data through September 30, 2026) in r/loseit, r/Fitness, r/keto, r/xxfitness, r/diet, r/intermittentfasting, r/1200isplenty, r/1500isplenty, r/caloriecount, r/nutrition, r/fitness30plus, r/Fitness_India, r/indianfitness, r/weightlosstips, r/Obesity, r/TDEE, r/Volumeeating, r/fasting, r/Semaglutide, r/Ozempic, r/AskReddit, r/Advice, r/NoStupidQuestions, r/AskMen, r/AskWomen, r/teenagers, r/EatCheapAndHealthy, r/HealthyFood, r/bodyweightfitness, r/running, r/progresspics and r/gainit, whose title asks some version of how to lose weight fast: "lose weight fast", "drop fat quickly", "fastest way to lose weight", "fast weight loss tips" and similar wordings. Titles that say "too fast", "so quickly" or "faster than" were left out, since they worry about losing weight too fast. When one person posted the same title in several subreddits, only the first thread was kept.
CommentsTop-level comments in those threads in the same period, excluding moderators, accounts on a known-bot list, removed and deleted comments, and replies under 60 characters: 9,335 comments.
SampleA random sample of 1,470 comments from 682 threads, 224 to 258 per year. Shares for all years are weighted by each year's number of comments.
LabelsNine labels: eat less or count calories; exercise; a named diet; fasting; cutting specific foods or drinks; drugs, supplements or a doctor; no fast way; another method; no advice. One label per comment, for the method it names first or stresses most.
LabellingTwo judges (Claude Haiku) labelled each comment with two differently worded instructions. They agreed on 80.3% of comments (Cohen's kappa 0.767), and a third model (Claude Sonnet) settled the rest.
Separate checkA separate check of 107 random final verdicts, read blind by a stronger model (Claude Opus): it agreed with 86, or 80.4%.
Thread titlesEach thread title was also labelled by two judges and an arbiter: does it ask how to lose weight fast, or not.
Missed threads10,277 thread titles in the same subreddits had a speed word and a weight word but didn't match the pattern. A judge (Claude Sonnet) read 200 of them at random; 42 asked how to lose weight fast.
Intervals95% intervals by bootstrap, resampling whole threads within each year, since comments in one thread aren't independent.

Planned before looking, and found while analysing

Each plan and what happened
PlanWhat happened
Planned before looking at results: eating less would be the most common advice among method commentsHeld. It also stayed on top in each of seven other ways of counting it, of which I planned four in advance (each judge alone, only the comments both judges agreed on, without weights) and added three after the first results: without r/AskReddit, without the general-question subreddits, and only the threads that ask
Planned: a noticeable share would say there is no fast wayHeld: 8.0% (95% interval 6.4% to 9.7%)
Planned: drugs, supplements or a doctor would come up more in 2025 than in 2021Not supported: the two years' intervals overlap
Found while analysing: the first title pattern caught threads about money, respect and fasting as a wordThe pattern was narrowed once before labelling. After a first round of labels, the pattern was narrowed again and duplicate threads were dropped, which kept 1,470 of 1,800 labelled comments; the earliest set of labels was discarded
Found while analysing: some threads don't ask for a methodThread titles were labelled separately, and the shares for threads that ask are shown next to the shares for all threads
Planned: intervals for single commentsReplaced by a bootstrap over whole threads, since replies in one thread aren't independent

Conflict of interest: KissMyPost makes Reddit research tools. Funding: none.

Corrections: contact me; each fix gets a dated note on this page.

The data

What the files hold
ItemWhat
FilesShares of comments by main advice, shares by year for five kinds of advice, shares by subreddit, and shares for threads that ask.
PrivacyNo comment text, thread titles or usernames.
LicenseCC BY 4.0.
More Reddit numbersOverall Reddit numbers are on the Reddit statistics page.
Share of comments by main advice and year, with 95% intervals
PeriodComments labelledEat lessA named dietExerciseDrugs, supplements or a doctorNo fast way
In all of 202125425.6% (20.5% to 31.0%)12.2% (8.8% to 15.8%)10.6% (6.7% to 14.6%)4.3% (2.2% to 6.4%)4.7% (2.4% to 7.3%)
In all of 202224723.1% (17.3% to 29.7%)13.4% (9.4% to 17.8%)13.0% (8.3% to 18.6%)6.5% (3.2% to 10.5%)8.5% (4.8% to 12.4%)
In all of 202323221.1% (15.3% to 26.1%)10.8% (6.6% to 15.6%)10.3% (6.8% to 14.1%)5.2% (2.4% to 8.2%)8.6% (5.2% to 13.3%)
In all of 202425523.9% (18.0% to 29.9%)8.2% (5.0% to 12.2%)12.9% (8.6% to 17.4%)5.9% (3.2% to 8.7%)7.5% (3.6% to 11.6%)
In all of 202525824.8% (18.7% to 30.8%)12.0% (6.9% to 18.5%)9.3% (5.4% to 13.4%)5.0% (2.3% to 8.2%)8.5% (4.1% to 13.6%)
In 2026, January to September22425.4% (19.9% to 32.7%)11.6% (6.6% to 17.4%)6.7% (3.6% to 9.8%)3.6% (1.4% to 5.9%)9.8% (6.0% to 14.2%)
  • CSVComments by main adviceShare of sampled comments for each of nine kinds of main advice, with 95% intervals.
  • CSVEat less, by yearShare of comments whose main advice is eating less or counting calories, from 2021 to 2026, with comments labelled and 95% intervals.
  • CSVA named diet, by yearShare of comments whose main advice is a named diet, by year, with 95% intervals.
  • CSVExercise, by yearShare of comments whose main advice is exercise, by year, with 95% intervals.
  • CSVDrugs, supplements or a doctor, by yearShare of comments whose main advice is a drug, a supplement or a doctor, by year, with 95% intervals.
  • CSVNo fast way, by yearShare of comments that say there is no fast way and give no method, by year, with 95% intervals.
  • CSVBy subredditComments in the sample per subreddit and the share of method comments that say to eat less.
  • CSVThreads that askShares for all threads and for threads whose title asks how to lose weight fast.
  • PNGMain chart as an imageThe chart of main advice on this page as an image.

Zenodo DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24314418

Questions people ask

What is the fastest way to lose weight, according to Reddit?

In a random sample of top-level replies under fast weight-loss threads in selected subreddits, the most common method is eating less or counting calories: 35.7% of the comments that recommend a method say so. That's what they recommend, not proof that it works.

How often do Reddit replies recommend drugs, supplements or a doctor?

Rarely as the main advice. Ozempic wasn't counted separately; in this sample, drugs, supplements or a doctor were the main advice in 5.2% of comments, with no clear change between 2021 and 2025.

How often do Reddit replies say there is no fast way to lose weight?

Some do. In this sample, 8.0% of comments say there's no safe or lasting fast way, or tell the asker to go slowly, without naming a method.

How many Reddit replies give no advice at all?

About a quarter: 25.2% of the top-level comments in this sample recommend nothing. They might ask a question back, tell a story or joke.

Search any phrase since 2005

See when a word or phrase took off on Reddit, in which subreddits and who used it.

Or see a full subreddit report first, free, no sign-up

Latest research

About the data

KissMyPost is a Reddit analytics tool: it reads a subreddit's history (posts, comments, removals, rules) and tells you when to post, what format works and who writes there. This study uses the same data: public Reddit posts and comments back to 2005.

What KissMyPost does

All KissMyPost tools

New Reddit studies by email, about one email per study. Unsubscribe anytime.

About the author

Dmytro Krutytskyi is the founder of KissMyPost, a Reddit analytics tool. He studies what online communities talk about, who writes in them and how audiences overlap, and writes up what the data shows here, with the method and the numbers. Questions about the data, or need a cut we didn't publish? Write to him directly.

LinkedInORCIDTelegram @krutytskyi

Cite this study

Krutytskyi, D. (2026). How to lose weight fast, according to Reddit: what commenters recommend most. KissMyPost Research. https://kissmypost.com/research/how-to-lose-weight-fast-reddit

Data: Krutytskyi, D. (2026). Main advice in Reddit replies to fast weight-loss threads, 2021 to 2026 [Data set]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24314418